
Most business owners who think about changing accountant share the same worry. It isn’t the cost, and it isn’t finding someone new. It’s the hassle.
Will it mean an awkward conversation? Could records go missing? What if it take months to sort out?
Here's what’s really involved, and why, in many cases, the best advice is not to move at all.
Most people worry that switching accountant will be a hassle. In practice, it can take a single sentence. Edith Woodward and Michael Carthy explain why it’s worth talking to your current accountant first, and what really happens when you decide to move.
Business owners meet new accountants all the time. For example, networking events, adverts, cold calls and online ads all bring new offers.
Our view is simple, though. If you’re working well with your accountant, stay where you are. After all, a strong relationship with an accountant who knows your business is valuable. They should be with you through growth and through the difficult times. In fact, when something goes wrong, they should be the first person you call.
If something isn’t working, the first step isn’t to leave. Instead, it’s to talk.
Sit down with your accountant and explain the problem. They may be able to fix it. They may also have their own feedback for you. Either way, an honest conversation often puts things right.
On the other hand, letting frustration build is the worst thing you can do. Relationships change. Sometimes a business outgrows its accountant. Other times, needs simply move apart, and nobody is at fault. So if talking doesn’t help, that’s when it’s time to look elsewhere.
When it is time to move, the process is straightforward.
First, you let your current accountant know you’re moving. It can be a single sentence. “I’m moving to [new firm]. They’ll be in touch.”
That’s all you need to do. Next, your new accountant contacts your previous one and requests the information they need. Accountants call this formal handover professional clearance. Its purpose is to make sure nothing gets lost and the transition goes smoothly.
As a result, you don’t need a difficult meeting. Nor do you need to gather years of records yourself. Your new accountant does most of the work for you.
Feeling nervous is natural. In fact, it’s the same feeling as changing your car or switching software. Will the new one do everything the old one did?
That’s why talking matters so much. Tell your new accountant what mattered most about your old arrangement, and also what you want to be different. A good firm will listen and make it work for you.

If your accountant relationship is working, protect it. However, if it isn’t, start with an honest conversation. Then, once you’ve done that and still feel stuck, we’re happy to talk through what a move would look like for your business.
Get in touch: carthyaccountants.co.uk/contact